Robert Hodgins: Graphics
-
THE MARKET
In recent years, much has been said about the softening of the market for Robert Hodgins' art. This trend is evident in data from Mutual Art, showing that the average price for his works dropped from around $25,000 in 2016 to about $3,500 by 2024.
This variation is testimony to the vagaries of the art market. A market which rises and falls like any other. At the turn of the century paying millions of rands for a painting by Robert Hodgins may have been inconceivable, as was the reaction when the first painting by a South Africa artist (JH Pierneef, Extensive Landscape Northern Transvaal, 1949, in this instance) surpassed the R100,000 mark, selling for R120,000 in 1985. This was only exceeded six years later when a painting by Gerard Sekoto, Six Pence a Door, 1947, achieved R186,000 at auction, and Irma Stern's Still Life of Delphiniums became the first painting to surpass the R200,000 mark, in 1995. That is only 30 years ago. And today, the same paintings would likely achieve more than R20m each.
Art dealer and curator Warren Siebrits highlights Hodgins' remarkable rise in prestige and value after retiring from teaching at age 63 to paint full-time. He notes that in 2002, a major Hodgins painting from the Goodman Gallery could be purchased for less than R40,000. In contrast, Hodgins' record sale-R2.5 million for the 1995 painting J'Accuse, which addresses the infamous Dreyfus Affair-reflects the growing recognition of his historical importance.
Siebrits critiques the South African art-collecting establishment for its traditional focus on oil paintings, often neglecting works on paper. Prints and drawings, he argues, remain under-appreciated and misunderstood, with Hodgins' works on paper being no exception.
During his tenure as art advisor for the Gencor Collection (later the BHP Billiton and South 32 Art Collections), Siebrits oversaw the acquisition of over 600 contemporary artworks for less than R2 million. This included 80 works by William Kentridge and 30 by Hodgins, amongst others. By 2012, Siebrits observed that the collection, amassed during a period of economic and political uncertainty in the mid-1990s, had become nearly irreplaceable in quality and value.
Similarly, the art market of 2024, characterised by low growth, and epitomised by events such as an 88% decline in Sotheby's core earnings and a 25% drop in auction sales (as reported by the Financial Times), mirrors the difficult conditions of the mid-1990s. Indeed, creating a strong buyer's market with foreseeable gains likely to be similar to those experienced by Gencor. -
THE ARTWORK
In his 2002 article Undiscovered at 82, Kendell Geers noted the irony of Hodgins' satirical portrayals of businessmen in stuffed suits-figures resembling the very people who purchased his works as investments, seemingly unaware of their implication as subjects.
Geers highlights how Hodgins consistently focused on the human figure, particularly the metaphorical character of Alfred Jarry's Père Ubu-a pathetic, tyrannical, and comical figure lost in his delusional kingdom. For Hodgins, Ubu represented the darker aspects of human nature, embodying themes of power, greed, and absurdity.
Michael Godby similarly emphasises Hodgins' use of Ubu as a personification of maniacal and malevolent power. Ubu appears across Hodgins' oeuvre as a general, lawyer, politician, interrogator, and patriarch, serving as both witness and emblem of evil in historical and fictional contexts.
Through Hodgins' lens, Ubu becomes a proxy for humanity's flaws, present in varying degrees throughout his works. As Geers succinctly puts it, Hodgins approached these subjects "with Hogarth's satirical eye and Monty Python's humour." -
Robert Hodgins, Attorney-at-Law, 1986
-
Robert Hodgins, Medal, 1987
-
Robert Hodgins, The Senator from Mississippi, 1987
-
Robert Hodgins, An English Sphinx, 1988/90
-
Robert Hodgins, These Sundays, (triptych), 1997/8
-
Robert Hodgins, Well, here we are..., 2008
-
Sources:
Geers, Kendell (2002), Undiscovered at 82. In Atkinson, Brenda (et al), Robert Hodgins. Cape Town: Tafelberg, pp.62-68.
Godby, Michael (2002), The Old Man Mad About Painting. In Atkinson, Brenda (et al), Robert Hodgins. Cape Town: Tafelberg, pp.70-78.
Siebrits, Warren (2012), Confessions of an Art Advisor: Robert Hodgins and the South African Art Market. In Buys, Anthea, A Lasting Impression: The Robert Hodgins Print Archive. Johannesburg: Wits Art Museum, pp.173-191.